“How Can You Tell If a Perennial Is ‘Marginally Hardy?'”

by | Updated: Sep 14, 2021

How to tell marginally hardy perennials from cold hardy perennials

It was a winter week to make a gardener shudder.

In February 2021, an arctic blast covered the western United States like a frosty ice pack from the kitchen freezer. Where I live in Colorado, the high temperature for several days was a not-so-balmy zero degrees. The nightly lows danced between -15 and -20 degrees below zero.

(It may have gotten even colder where you live!)

In the spring, most of my marginally hardy perennials did not come back.


Marginally hardy perennials are your “iffy” plants.

They could come back after winter. They should come back if your winter is mild. But if you get extreme colds or tough winter conditions, they’ll die.

So, if you want to know, “How can you tell if a perennial is marginally hardy?”, read on.

You’ll find a helpful way to tell if a perennial is marginally hardy.

Use this tip to choose plants that are more likely to handle our tough western winters and return to your garden!

Winters in states like Colorado and Wyoming are tough on perennial flower plants.

First, a disclaimer…

(Don’t you love when people lead with disclaimers?)

There are MANY things that can affect whether perennials will survive winter and return to your western garden in the spring — things like moisture, drought, wind, root health, micro-climates in your landscape, etc.

But to keep this simple…

We’re going to focus on winter temperatures.

Every plant has a threshold for how cold it can get over the winter and still survive.

If it gets too cold, it will die.

Your marginally hardy perennials won’t come back if it gets too cold for them over the winter.

And this is where plant hardiness zones come into play!

If you’re new to plant hardiness zones, don’t worry. I’ve included a brief explanation below. Or, you can learn about zones here, including how to find your garden’s zone.

Here’s a quick way to think about it.

When you buy plants, you’ll see zone numbers on their plant tags.

This plant tag for this flower plant shows USDA plant hardiness zones 3-9.

These numbers are a guide to how cold (or warm) it can get in the winter without killing the plant.

Zone numbers are kind of like a thermometer:

  • Plants with lower zone numbers can survive colder winters.
  • Plants with higher zone numbers can survive warmer winters.

The flower pictured above, Red Birds in a Tree, can survive very cold winter temperatures (in chilly zone 3), up through warm winter temperatures (in balmy zone 9).

Let’s say you live in plant hardiness zone 5 — like much of the Front Range of Colorado.

You find a flower plant you want to buy.

The plant tag says it grows in zones 5-9. (Remember, lower zone numbers mean the plant can handle colder winters.)

This plant tag for this iceplant says USDA plant hardiness zones 5-9.

You live in zone 5, and the lowest zone that’s suggested for this plant is zone 5.

This perennial is marginally hardy where you live.

It’s right on the edge of being able to survive the coldest winter temperatures that are expected in your area.

If you get a winter with extreme lows, this plant may not make it, especially if it’s newly planted.

You may be more successful growing this perennial if you wait until the spring to plant it. That way, it has the entire summer to get established in your garden.

The same is true if you find a plant that grows well in zones 6-9.

Again, we’re looking at that first number.

This plant doesn’t like winters as cold as the ones that are possible in your area.

This plant is only marginally hardy where you live. If temperatures get too cold over winter, it won’t come back.

Still with me?

Let’s continue our example and talk about:

How to identify hardy perennials (which are sometimes referred to as “cold hardy perennials”)

Again, let’s say your garden is in plant hardiness zone 5.

You find a flower plant that grows well in zones 4-8 or zones 3-9, like Red Birds in a Tree below.

This plant tag shows USDA plant hardiness zones 3-9.

This plant is a hardy perennial where you live.

It can survive colder winter temperatures than you normally get.

Related tips that may interest you:

Get more tips like these

Scroll down to the yellow box below, and plant your email. You’ll receive helpful tips to grow beautiful flowers in your western garden. (No green thumb required!)

© 2020-2021, Go West Gardener
You’re welcome to share a link to this article on social media sites, but no other re-use in any form without written permission.

You may also like …

Ann from Go West Gardener with her flowerpots and garden

Hey there, I'm Ann

I’m a Certified Colorado Gardener, dog mama and Midwesterner-turned-Colorado girl. I help budding gardeners in the intermountain west get more confident with flower gardening, so you can create an outdoor space you love. More about Ann >>

Free flowerpot mini-training for summer: How to get more colorful blooms from your flowers in containers

3 proven ways to get more color from your flowerpots

What type of flowerpot gardener are you?

What type of flowerpot gardener are you?

Recent posts

5 Helpful Tips for Buying Spring Flowering Bulbs in the Fall

5 Helpful Tips for Buying Spring Flowering Bulbs in the Fall

Let’s say you’d like to grow pretty spring flowers in your garden, like tulips or daffodils. Awesome! These spring flowers grow from bulbs that you plant in the fall. Here are a few examples of spring flowering bulbs: In this week’s tip, you’ll get 5 helpful tips for...

“When Should I Empty My Flowerpots?”

“When Should I Empty My Flowerpots?”

In the fall, one of the questions that often comes up is: "When should I empty my flowerpots?" There are different schools of thought on when to empty your flowerpots, so I'm going to share several options. That way, you can decide which makes the most sense for you....

Hey there, budding western gardener!

Plant your email in the box to the right to get simple flower garden tips, so you can create an outdoor space you loooooove.

Success! Now check your email to confirm.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This